Catholics and Protestants should not be enemies! A lack of a robust Christianity being willing to say that some things are just plain wrong leads to the aid and comfort of the enemies of Western civilization.

It was the ending blurb which truly amused me:

Made by History takes readers beyond the headlines with articles written and edited by professional historians. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of The Inquirer.

No, the editors of The Philadelphia Inquirer would definitely not want anyone, anyone! to have positive views of conservative Christianity! Whoever publicizes stories on the newspaper’s Twitter account chose not, at my publication time of 9:55 AM EST, to tweet out this story. Even the headline tells you about their disgust:

The roots of the religious right are a lot older than most people know

The alliance between conservative Catholics and evangelical Protestants dates not to the 1970s, but to popular radio broadcasters in the 1940s who brought them together to fight Godless Communism.


by Chase Castle, Made By History | Monday, November 16, 2026 | 8:01 AM EST

On Sept. 24, the Catholic Church beatified Fulton Sheen, leaving him one step from sainthood. Many Americans remember Sheen as a television bishop in the 1950s, the host of Life Is Worth Living.

You can practically hear the sneering in their voices when they use the term “religious right”.

While television made Sheen a recognizable face, his radio broadcasts from the 1940s would sound especially familiar today. They captured the moment when conservative Catholics and evangelical Protestants, long rivals, began to fear secularism more than each other — and the first hints of the rise of the contemporary religious right.

Most accounts cite the 1970s as the moment when these two religious groups joined together politically, and most credit fights over the Equal Rights Amendment, abortion and gay rights for bringing Catholic and evangelical activists into common cause.

However, the growing alliance between the two religious groups could already be heard a generation earlier, in the 1940s, on Sheen’s radio show The Catholic Hour and fundamentalist preacher Charles Fuller’s Old Fashioned Revival Hour.

The author continues to tell us about the conflicts between Catholics and Protestants, with various Protestant denominations concerned that we mackerel snappers were beholden to a foreign prince, the Pope, and the too-common belief that Catholics were not Christian.

I got that last just a couple of years ago when a Catechism student of mine was upset because one of her classmates had asked her why she was Catholic instead of Christian.

Then he notes how Catholics and Protestants became conservative allies, not on theology, but on the common political causes to which our faiths lead us: opposition to Communism and leftist movements which promote sin, immorality, and suppression of religion: sexual licentiousness, “if it feels good, do it,” the diminution of marriage, out-of-wedlock births, and secularizing everything. These things are not just religious issues but affect the fabric of Western civilization.

By the 1970s, this approach had become the playbook for the emerging religious right, when, for instance, Catholic activist Phyllis Schlafly and evangelical singer Anita Bryant led parallel battles against the ERA and gay rights. Schlafly emphasized common beliefs and enemies. She urged her followers to put doctrinal differences aside and focus on what they agreed upon.

Today, communism, secularism and liberal ideas about gender and sexuality still serve as a rallying cry on the political right — causes that bring together conservative evangelicals and Catholics. In June 2026, President Donald Trump told a Faith and Freedom Coalition audience of evangelicals and Catholics in Washington that “these ruthless communists will attack all religions, but in particular Christianity.”

Sadly, what I am seeing these days on Twitter — I refuse to call it 𝕏 — is back-and-forth religious bickering between Catholics and Protestants, with the added anti-Jewish messages of people like recent Catholic convert Carrie Prejean Hezboller Boller. Some like Mrs Boller are trying to expel Israel from Western civilization, and contributing to the rise of despicable anti-Semitism, while other tweeters attack Catholic beliefs.

I’m honest enough to admit that I see the Protestant attacks as worse than the Catholic responses, but I might see it that way due to prejudice because I am Catholic!

But whatever our doctrinal and theological differences, these things must not be allowed to distract us from the true lessons of Christianity: we have a common interest in promoting faith and a common interest in the life and culture of our country. The modernist tendencies which have promoted the schism in the Presbyterian Church are an issue, but just as worrisome are the supposed Christian leaders promoting definitely unChristian ideas. You cannot in any way claim to be a Christian and support prenatal infanticide.

Western civilization promotes tolerance, but a lack of a robust Christianity being willing to say that some things are just plain wrong leads to the aid and comfort of the enemies of Western civilization.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *