We noted the story of a Philadelphia car owner shooting and killing the man who was trying to steal the catalytic converter from his automobile. The initial report was that the owner had a license for his firearm; that report was erroneous:

A Philly man shot someone who was trying to steal his car. Now he’s charged with gun violations.

Police arrest car owner who fatally shot a would-be car thief Tuesday morning.

by Mensah M Dean | Wednesday, January 19, 2022 | 6:03 PM EST

The Cobbs Creek car owner who fatally shot a man who was trying to steal his car or its catalytic converter on Tuesday morning has been charged with carrying a gun without a license, Philadelphia police said Wednesday.

Steven Thompson, 54, who shot and killed one of three men who were tampering with his Acura as it was parked in front of his home in the 5800 block of Cobbs Creek Parkway, was charged with two counts of firearms violations.

On Tuesday, police incorrectly said Thompson had a permit to carry the gun he used to shoot the would-be car thief, Satario Natividad, 51, just after 8:15 a.m.

Further down:

Sherell Natividad welcomed news of an arrest in the death of her husband, a father of eight children and stepchildren.

“I’m getting a little bit of justice,” she said. “That’s good news to hear. You just can’t go shooting people and not expect there’s going to be consequences behind that.”

But she said murder charges were in order.

“He took my children’s father away from them. He took my husband away from me,” she said. “I want more. He murdered my husband. Even though he was doing wrong, he still murdered him. I can’t sleep, I can’t eat, I can’t do nothing.”

Sorry, Mrs Natividad, but your husband, the father of your children, was out breaking the law, was out stealing from people, and people defending their property might just do so violently. Replacement catalytic converters can cost over $1,000, so it’s not as though your husband stole a newspaper off someone’s porch. The Inquirer article noted that “Chief Inspector Frank Vanore said police found catalytic converters, tools and a handgun inside the Honda Accord.” That’s catalytic converters plural, so Mr Natividad and his fled-on-foot partners-in-crime had robbed at least two other car owners, had the tools to do so — which means that this was thought-out, and not a spur-of-the-moment thing — and had a firearm to boot. One assumes that the bad guys were prepared to meet any resistance with deadly force.

It’s not just that Mr Natividad “was doing wrong,” it was that he was a bad guy, a criminal.

Was this Mr Natividad’s first venture into crime? He was 51-years-old, not normally the age at which someone starts out on a felony theft career.

There is, of course, the obvious question: was Mrs Natividad aware of her husband’s criminal activities? Was she tolerating a criminal as her husband?

The only justice in this case would be dropping all of the charges against Mr Thompson: he took a criminal off of the streets of Philadelphia.